How to Choose a Trail Running Shoe

With such a wide variety of trail running shoes on the market, it can be hard to find the perfect one. This article breaks down the different kinds of trails to help you pick the best trail running shoe for your needs.

When you're ready to make the leap to trail running, choosing a trail running shoe will be your first step. And with so many options available, it's important to note that there are different shoes for different types of trails. This guide will help you identify these types of trails so you can select the appropriate shoe to match your needs and optimize your experience.


The Basics of Trail Running

With trails ranging anywhere from local dirt paths to muddy grasslands to alpine mountaintops comes the need for a shoe to match the demands of the terrain. And just as you always want the right tool for the job, so too should you choose the right trail shoe for what lies ahead.

Trail shoes are carefully engineered and developed for specific conditions, such as rocky trails or soft mud. The objective is to provide the runner with a combination of features that help with stability, speed, injury prevention, and comfort during the run. Therefore, choosing the correct trail running shoe is essential.


Types of Trails

man and woman running

Smooth Trails & Fireroads

Smooth trails are often shared by walkers, cyclists, and runners who desire to enjoy the outdoors away from the typical hustle and bustle of city life. These types of trails are usually well-developed and can be composed of crushed gravel or hard-packed dirt. Some paths may even be paved for better long-term use. These multi-use trails are conveniently located in neighborhood parks, metro areas, and small towns. There is little difficulty traversing these paths, which means they can generally be used by people of all fitness levels. Because of this, smooth trails and fire roads can be heavily trafficked, so it is important to be extra aware of other runners and walkers. On the plus side, crowded trails can bring you into contact with other like-minded folks seeking enjoyment when exercising in nature.

Best Shoes for Smooth Trails

The ideal shoe for these types of trails will be a versatile running shoe that can handle the daily rigor of both multi-use trails and pavement. These types of running shoes are similar to road shoes because they tend to feature more cushioning to offer comfort on the variety of terrain they will encounter. They are further characterized by lightweight, durable upper materials and mildly pronounced outsoles with short lugs for grip on off-road terrain. The outsole will provide just enough traction to handle gentle trails but not so much that they will feel uncomfortable on smooth pavement. These shoes are sometimes referred to as road-to-trail because they work well on paved routes and multi-use trails alike.


Rocky & Technical Trails

jeff browning running

These trails are characterized by rugged, rocky, and technical terrain with potentially steep inclines or declines. Rocky and technical trails require mental focus, agility, and shoes that inspire confidence. They must be approached with a general amount of navigational knowledge and an honest evaluation of one's trail readiness. Mountain trails are included in this category and they can be very rewarding, complete with beautiful, commanding views that offer a satisfying sense of accomplishment.

Best Shoes for Rocky & Technical Trails

Shoes best suited for rocky and technical trails are primarily defined by the aggressive sticky traction on their outsole and the durable upper materials. This enables wearers to maintain a grip on slippery or treacherous surfaces while bounding across the trail. In addition to grip, these shoes must protect the runner's feet from injuries caused by stone-bruising or abrasions. To accomplish that protection, a rock plate is typically embedded within the shoe's sole, and the uppers are made up of materials that shield the feet from sharp debris.


Fast Trails & Racing

If speed is your top priority on the trails, finding a shoe designed for fast trails and racing will help you optimize your performance. Since fast trail runs and races may happen on a wide variety of trails with a range of difficulties, you will need a shoe that can handle this varied terrain without slowing down. From beginner-rated trails that are slightly wider with smooth, hard-packed ground, to advanced trails with narrow single tracks, hairpin switchbacks, and steep climbs or drops, these fast trail and racing shoes can handle it all.

Best Shoes for Fast Trails & Racing

Whether zooming through rolling hills, gravel roads, rocky inclines, or hard-packed switchbacks, these shoes feature confidence-inspiring traction, responsive cushioning, and sometimes even midsole plates to help propel you to your fastest times. These trail racing shoes prioritize a secure-fitting upper and responsive midsole to provide slip-free confidence and a fast feel that will keep you pushing the pace throughout your run. With this focus on speed, fast trail and racing shoes tend to have a snug fit and less cushioning underfoot, making them less comfortable for everyday trail running and longer excursions.


Soft & Muddy Trails

man running in mud

Just as the name implies, these trails are characterized by their muddy, soft, and wet surfaces. Venturing out onto these soggy paths will likely result in mud-caked shoes and mud-stained clothing, but it will undoubtedly be a joy for the runner who doesn't mind getting a little messy. Often called "fell running," especially in the UK, soft trails can have a fair amount of rolling hills or take place near the countryside. Conditions on soft trails are even more compelling when they're subject to a wet climate or recent precipitation, which gives way to dynamic, muddy slopes.

Best Shoes for Soft Trails

For muddy, slippery trails, your go-to footwear should have deep, claw-like lugs that will dig into the soft terrain, keeping you on your feet rather than sprawling face-first into the slippery mud. The uppers on these types of shoes provide a supportive hold on your foot with a locked-in heel to keep you confident as you trudge through the slick landscape. Some uppers even feature waterproof material, identified in the shoe name by the letters GTX (GORE-TEX). The added benefit from GTX is dry feet on wet trails, but the downside will be less breathability and water drainage, so you will need to weigh the pros and cons and decide which features you value more.


Final Considerations

While this may seem like a lot of information, the most important part of choosing a solid trail shoe will be finding one that fits properly and feels comfortable. The product pages on our site offer a lot of information on the fit and purpose of each shoe, and you can also check our reviews to get a better sense of what other customers think. Educate yourself on where you plan to run and match the shoe for those conditions. These simple guidelines will help keep you on your feet and enjoying the beautiful journey of trail running.